If you care about clean lines, reliable engagement, and a tidy home, pedals and pedal protection matter. This guide covers the evolution of bicycle pedals, how today’s major systems compare, what they’re best for, and simple upkeep that extends their life. I’ll also share my personal setup—and how to keep sharp edges and road grime from scuffing walls, floors, and car interiors with dedicated pedal covers.
A short history of bicycle pedals
- Toe clips and straps (early 20th century): Metal cages and leather straps cinched the shoe to a platform pedal for power and retention. Still used by traditionalists and on the track.
- The “clipless” revolution (mid‑1980s): Ski‑binding‑style mechanisms eliminated straps. Look’s road system popularized the concept; engagement is into a cleat on the shoe.
- Off‑road clipless (1990s): Shimano’s SPD (2‑bolt) brought mud‑shedding, double‑sided entry, and walkable shoes to MTB and commuting.
- Alternatives and refinements (1990s–2000s): Speedplay (low stack, high float, dual‑sided road entry), Time (biomechanics‑friendly float), Crankbrothers (simple, mud‑clearing designs). Road variants like SPD‑SL and Look Keo emphasized larger platforms for stability.
- Modern flats renaissance (2010s–today): Wide, thin platforms with grippy pins and sticky shoes deliver impressive control for gravity, trail, and urban riders—no cleats required.
Pedal types: features, upkeep, and ideal use
Flat / Platform Pedals
What: Broad platforms (often with pins) used with flat‑soled shoes.
Strengths: Instant on/off, excellent foot mobility, confidence in technical terrain, zero cleat maintenance.
Watch‑outs: Less consistent foot placement; all‑out road efforts may feel less secure.
Upkeep: Grease axles, tighten/replace pins, keep bodies clean.
Best for: MTB (enduro/DH), dirt jump, urban/utility, casual rides, wet/icy days.
Toe Clips & Straps
What: Cage + strap over regular shoes.
Strengths: Low cost, classic look, versatile with footwear.
Watch‑outs: Exit learning curve; strap wear; not ideal in stop‑and‑go traffic.
Upkeep: Inspect straps/buckles; snug hardware.
Best for: Vintage builds, track, light touring by purists.
SPD (2‑bolt, Shimano & compatibles)
What: Compact, double‑sided mechanism; recessed cleats in walkable soles.
Strengths: Easy entry/exit, wide shoe choice, durable, low‑maintenance, great in mud. Most accessible MTB pedal system in the market.
Watch‑outs: Smaller road platform; some perceive less “locked‑in” stability in max sprints.
Upkeep: Occasional spring lube, clean mud, check cleat wear and bolt torque.
Best for: Gravel, XC, cyclocross, commuting, touring, indoor training.
SPD‑SL / Look Keo / Time Road (3‑bolt)
What: Single‑sided road pedals with larger platforms and exposed cleats.
Strengths: Broad, stable platform for sustained power; adjustable float options.
Watch‑outs: Cleats wear with walking; can be slippery off‑bike; the carbon leaf spring found on higher-end Look and Time Road pedals (like the Xpresso) can crack after prolonged use and will require replacement.
Upkeep: Replace worn cleats; clean contact surfaces; set spring tension; check carbon leaf spring regularly for the higher-end models
Best for: Road racing, triathlon, high‑power endurance riding.
Shop Tour de Colligo to enjoy road racing while being off the saddle!
Speedplay (now Wahoo Speedplay)
What: Dual‑sided road entry; much of the mechanism lives in the cleat; low stack, generous float.
Strengths: Precise fit/float tuning, easy two‑sided entry, cornering clearance, light weight.
Watch‑outs: More cleat parts; needs periodic lubrication and fastener checks.
Upkeep: Grease ports (on certain models), clean/lube cleat hardware, check bolts.
Best for: Performance road, TT/tri, riders needing fine float adjustment.
Time ATAC / Crankbrothers (MTB‑oriented)
What: Mud‑shedding off‑road mechanisms with a distinct float feel.
Strengths: Excellent in bad conditions; simple, predictable engagement; more float than the SPD system.
Watch‑outs: Unique cleat wear patterns; monitor release consistency.
Upkeep: Clean; lube springs as specified; replace cleats when worn.
Best for: MTB, gravel, cyclocross, rough‑terrain riders prioritizing float.
How to choose by use case
- Commuting & urban: SPD or flats for walkability and quick exits.
- Gravel, XC, cyclocross: SPD or Time/Crankbrothers for mud performance.
- Road endurance/racing: SPD‑SL, Look Keo, Time road, or Speedplay for platform stability.
- One‑bike‑does‑all: SPD is a versatile “set and forget.”
Editor’s choice: why I’m riding SPD right now
I started road cycling on Speedplays and still love what they do well: true double‑sided clip‑in, excellent walkability with covers, low stack, and feathery weight. The flip side for me has been upkeep—cleats have multiple small parts that can loosen or break over time, and they ask for more regular TLC than other systems.
That’s why I’m switching to SPD. It’s still double‑sided for quick, intuitive engagement. Some riders feel it’s a touch less stable under max sprint torque, and yes, the system can be a bit heavier than a pure road setup. In return, I get:
- Lower maintenance: Fewer fiddly parts; occasional spring lube and a wipe‑down is usually enough.
- Durability: The mechanism shrugs off grit and bad weather.
- Shoe variety and walkability: From race‑stiff XC to commuter shoes, all with recessed cleats for real‑world walking.
Pro tip: If SPD‑style shoes aren’t your look, convert many 3‑bolt road shoes to 2‑bolt with the Shimano SM-SH41 cleat adapter so you keep a sleeker silhouette but run SPD hardware.
Care and safety fundamentals for any system
- Float and tension: Set for comfort and knee health first; tighten only as needed.
- Replace worn cleats: Sloppy engagement or unpredictable release = time to swap.
-
Torque and threadlocker: Use a torque wrench on cleat bolts; a dab of medium threadlocker prevents surprises.
- Grease the pedal threads: No one wants a stuck pedal while you are trying to remove it. Make sure the threads are greased before you put them on the crank to save you from the misery in the future.
- Keep it clean: Road salt and mud accelerate wear. Brush debris away and add a light dry lube to springs/mechanisms.
- Inspect pedal axles: Check for play or noise; service or replace before they fail.
What's the best way to protect your pedals when you are not riding?
While picking the perfect pedal depends on your riding terrain and style, and is 100% personal, the best way to protect your pedals is always to put on a pair of bike pedal covers when you are not riding them. Such protection is much needed for bike storage at home or when you are transporting your bike in a car.
- Protect your space: Covered pedals won’t tattoo walls, floors, or car interiors with pins or metal edges.
- Protect the bike: Covers prevent grime transfer when storing multiple bikes together.
- Travel & indoor storage: Essential for hallways, elevators, cars, and apartments.
- Courtesy & safety: Fewer snags on clothing and upholstery; fewer accidental nicks.
FAQs
- Do pedal covers fit clipless and flat pedals?
- Yes—choose the size that matches your pedal style (Road, SPD/2‑bolt, or MTB/Platform) for a secure fit.
- Can I ride with pedal covers on?
- No. They’re for storage and transport only. Always remove covers before pedaling.
- How do I care for pedal covers?
- Shake out grit, spot‑clean with mild soap, and air dry. Avoid harsh solvents or high heat.
- What’s the best all‑round pedal system?
- For versatility, durability, and walkability, SPD is hard to beat. For road‑only power transfer, many prefer SPD‑SL/Look or Speedplay. Pick based on terrain, footwear, and maintenance tolerance.
